Zach did not like getting his fingers dirty - kind of an essential task for finger painting - but I substituted a basting brush and spatula instead. He liked that much better.
Here is Zach looking very Princess Leia-esque:

To find the finger paint recipe, see here. I used the Original Recipe (but not for fried chicken). This activity also reminded me of a great childhood memory when my mom would make homemade play dough. It smells heavenly. Here's the recipe:
2 cups flour
1 tbsp. alum
1 cup salt
2 cups boiling water
2 tbsp. baby oil
Mix flour, salt, and alum (a spice). Add boiling water and mix. Knead in baby oil.